Home » News » Crime
August 01. 2012 9:12PM
Judge postpones murder trial after defendant's lawyer quits
MANCHESTER — The scheduled Sept. 10 court date for Tony Hebert's second-degree murder trial in Hillsborough County Superior Court North was scrapped Wednesday after his private attorney withdrew from the case for nonpayment of fees.
Hebert, 28, formerly of 692 Rimmon St., is accused of shooting Pablo Samniego, 21, in the face July 17, 2011, at Ferry and South Main streets.
One of the second-degree murder charges accuses Hebert of recklessly causing Samniego's death. The other alleges he knowingly caused Samniego's death.
Police said Samniego was walking with a friend that Saturday morning, just before 3 a.m., when a car pulled up next to them and, after a brief conversation, the man in the car shot Samniego in the face.
Hebert was arrested two days later. A status hearing in the case had been scheduled for Wednesday in Hillsborough County Superior Court North, with a motions hearing set for Aug. 10, in anticipation of the trial starting in September.
But Hebert's attorney, William Sullivan, told Judge David Garfunkel that he hasn't been paid for the past 30 days, despite a contract with Hebert's family, and hasn't been able to resolve the problem.
“Either you're moving to withdraw or you're not,” said Garfunkel, who then said he was granting the withdrawal motion and would appoint a public defender to represent Hebert.
Senior Assistant Attorney General Jeffrey Strelzin said Hebert originally was represented by public defenders Caroline Brown and Eric Raymond. Strelzin said Hebert had objections to Brown and essentially fired her, and that Todd Russell was appointed, but Hebert still wasn't happy and sought the private counsel.
“The defendant was extremely unhappy with his public defenders,” said Strelzin, who asked that contract counsel be appointed to represent Hebert.
Garfunkel said contract counsel — a private attorney contracted to represent defendants financially eligible for public defenders — don't handle murder cases.
Raymond, who was in the courtroom Wednesday, then joined defense and prosecution attorneys in a bench conference, after which Garfunkel told Hebert he was again appointing public defenders to represent him. Garfunkel said the planned Sept. 10 trial date is no longer feasible and asked Hebert to waive his right to a speedy trial, which he did.
Garfunkel said Raymond and Sullivan need to meet and arrange for the transfer of information and materials and that next Friday's planned motions hearing will be a structuring conference.
A new trial date will be set.
Hebert, 28, formerly of 692 Rimmon St., is accused of shooting Pablo Samniego, 21, in the face July 17, 2011, at Ferry and South Main streets.
One of the second-degree murder charges accuses Hebert of recklessly causing Samniego's death. The other alleges he knowingly caused Samniego's death.
Police said Samniego was walking with a friend that Saturday morning, just before 3 a.m., when a car pulled up next to them and, after a brief conversation, the man in the car shot Samniego in the face.
Hebert was arrested two days later. A status hearing in the case had been scheduled for Wednesday in Hillsborough County Superior Court North, with a motions hearing set for Aug. 10, in anticipation of the trial starting in September.
But Hebert's attorney, William Sullivan, told Judge David Garfunkel that he hasn't been paid for the past 30 days, despite a contract with Hebert's family, and hasn't been able to resolve the problem.
“Either you're moving to withdraw or you're not,” said Garfunkel, who then said he was granting the withdrawal motion and would appoint a public defender to represent Hebert.
Senior Assistant Attorney General Jeffrey Strelzin said Hebert originally was represented by public defenders Caroline Brown and Eric Raymond. Strelzin said Hebert had objections to Brown and essentially fired her, and that Todd Russell was appointed, but Hebert still wasn't happy and sought the private counsel.
“The defendant was extremely unhappy with his public defenders,” said Strelzin, who asked that contract counsel be appointed to represent Hebert.
Garfunkel said contract counsel — a private attorney contracted to represent defendants financially eligible for public defenders — don't handle murder cases.
Raymond, who was in the courtroom Wednesday, then joined defense and prosecution attorneys in a bench conference, after which Garfunkel told Hebert he was again appointing public defenders to represent him. Garfunkel said the planned Sept. 10 trial date is no longer feasible and asked Hebert to waive his right to a speedy trial, which he did.
Garfunkel said Raymond and Sullivan need to meet and arrange for the transfer of information and materials and that next Friday's planned motions hearing will be a structuring conference.
A new trial date will be set.
- UPDATE: Elderly Nashua couple were stabbed to death - 2
- Rochester woman under arrest in underage party - 0
- Mass. police officer indicted in Salem sex assault - 1
- Russian national indicted over phony debit, credit cards - 0
- Hampton man indicted for distributing child porn - 0
- Mother of drowned baby gets prison time - 6
- Former Londonderry coach indicted in sex assault of two girls - 1
- Manchester resident interrupts burglary - 0
- Auburn woman struck in head with bottle of cologne - 1
NH man to be tried in $13 million mortgage fraud scheme
READER COMMENTS: 0- 21 in Concord wake to find their tires slashed - 0
- House proposes special session to decide Medicaid expansion - 1
- UPDATE: Police say man found dead outside Wall Street Towers jumped - 4
- House, Senate at standoff over vaccines, voter registration bill - 0
- Rochester parents called to court to answer for truant children - 2
- Exeter High teachers' resignations announced at meeting - 0
- LeBron, Heat edge Spurs in OT, force Game 7 - 0
- Santos drives in three as Curve beat Fisher Cats in 10 - 0
- Large billboards grabbing attention on Route 101 in Epping - 3
Students being evaluated at scene of Salem bus crash
READER COMMENTS: 0- Should applicants for jobless benefits have to pass a drug test?
- Yes
- 78%
- No
- 22%
- Total Votes: 1424





