Home » Opinion » Editorials
August 12. 2012 7:20PM
Death scare politics: Same lie, different year
It is the sort of heart-wrenching anecdote that cold-hearted political operatives love. As a hard-working family faced the nightmare of cancer, a mother’s fight to save her life was undercut by poor health insurance coverage. Her plight wasn’t important to the Republican Party and its wealthy nominee. Therefore, only Democrats can be trusted to fix America’s health-care system.
John Kerry told one version of that story in 2004. Barack Obama’s key supporters have now attacked Mitt Romney with another. Both presidential campaigns found a desperate family, took advantage of their candor, then twisted the facts for political advantage. In short, they lied.
Eight years ago, two loyal New Hampshire Democrats, Mary Ann and John Knowles of Nashua, told Sen. Kerry about their personal and financial struggles during her battle with cancer. The Massachusetts senator conveniently rewrote their painful story to fit his script, asserting in his acceptance speech at the national convention that poor health insurance coverage forced Mrs. Knowles to work every day during her chemotherapy. He knew that was not true. When a New Hampshire Sunday News correspondent uncovered his exaggerations, Kerry’s aides angrily pushed back, insisting that he had been misinterpreted. But the bogus story promptly disappeared from the nominee’s stump speech.
Last week’s lie was bigger and colder. A super PAC run by a former Barack Obama political adviser released a misleading TV ad that linked Mitt Romney’s business career to the death of the wife of a Kansas steelworker whose mill was closed by Bain Capital. Critical facts were omitted. The employee did not lose his health insurance when laid off; his wife was not diagnosed with cancer until five years later. Even liberal media such as MSNBC and PolitiFact quickly joined Republicans in condemning the ad, but the President’s campaign has refused to criticize it.
The issue at hand isn’t health care. It is basic decency. A campaign that lies about cancer will lie about absolutely anything. Any political operative who defends such ads sacrifices all credibility. A candidate who hesitates to denounce such dishonorable tactics is unworthy of any office, let alone the presidency.
John Kerry told one version of that story in 2004. Barack Obama’s key supporters have now attacked Mitt Romney with another. Both presidential campaigns found a desperate family, took advantage of their candor, then twisted the facts for political advantage. In short, they lied.
Eight years ago, two loyal New Hampshire Democrats, Mary Ann and John Knowles of Nashua, told Sen. Kerry about their personal and financial struggles during her battle with cancer. The Massachusetts senator conveniently rewrote their painful story to fit his script, asserting in his acceptance speech at the national convention that poor health insurance coverage forced Mrs. Knowles to work every day during her chemotherapy. He knew that was not true. When a New Hampshire Sunday News correspondent uncovered his exaggerations, Kerry’s aides angrily pushed back, insisting that he had been misinterpreted. But the bogus story promptly disappeared from the nominee’s stump speech.
Last week’s lie was bigger and colder. A super PAC run by a former Barack Obama political adviser released a misleading TV ad that linked Mitt Romney’s business career to the death of the wife of a Kansas steelworker whose mill was closed by Bain Capital. Critical facts were omitted. The employee did not lose his health insurance when laid off; his wife was not diagnosed with cancer until five years later. Even liberal media such as MSNBC and PolitiFact quickly joined Republicans in condemning the ad, but the President’s campaign has refused to criticize it.
The issue at hand isn’t health care. It is basic decency. A campaign that lies about cancer will lie about absolutely anything. Any political operative who defends such ads sacrifices all credibility. A candidate who hesitates to denounce such dishonorable tactics is unworthy of any office, let alone the presidency.
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: Ready, get set for some more fun runs - 0
- Scrap metal proves a ready source of cash - 0
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: It's 'art with six-pack benefits' - 1
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: We all enjoy a breath of Fresh Air - 0
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: Webster House gets ready for its Super Raffle - 0
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: Judge's box, not dance floor, was right spot - 0
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: Cleaning out the closet can help others - 0
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: Getting in the mood for St. Pat's Day - 0
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: 'Dancing with Stars' on Elm Street - 0
Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: A new acupuncture experience
READER COMMENTS: 0- Talk of UNH logo change brings out passions - 0
- John Habib's City Sports: Gosselin stepping down as city AD - 0
- Lackey sharp as Red Sox pound Cleveland, Masterson - 0
- Manchester Vet Center just 'a great place' - 0
- NHIAA Roundup: Bedford netmen earn spot in state final - 0
- NHIAA Scoreboard, May 24, 2013 - 0
- NHIAA Div. I Track: Lynch, North boys prevail - 0
- Two found dead in Belmont; one man detained as part of investigation - 0
- Weather this weekend may be more like Veterans Day - 0
Sox in the city: World champs' appearance highlighted Gill Stadium opening
READER COMMENTS: 0
Sorry, no question available



